A silly exercise to compare dudes across different positions. But this is basically how much I’ve enjoyed watching each of these guys play each week. Basically “how good are they doing what they do”

I’m not going to rank guys who haven’t played much O or D reps or guys who got injured early like Diontae Johnson and Cam Heyward

1	TJ Watt	Watt else can be said about the best defender in the NFL?
2	Alex Highsmith	He eats so good
3	George Pickens	Absurdly talented, horribly used
4	Keeanu Benton	Young rook has looked waaay better than I thought, need more PT
5	Joey Porter Jr.	ditto from above
6	Minkah Fitzpatrick	Hasn’t made the splash plays that we’re accustomed to seeing
7	Larry Ogunjobi	Holding down the d-line admirably in Cam’s absence
8	Elandon Roberts	Insane run defender, love watching him explode into the hole and make tackles
9	Broderick Jones	Only been 2 games but his last vs. Balt was AWESOME
10	Jaylen Warren	Legit explosive af and used on better playcalls than Najee
11	Cole Holcomb	Best LB we’ve had since Shaz (that isn’t saying much lol)
12	Najee Harris	Suffers from most his runs being telegraphed to the defense, almost no holes
13	Montravius Adams	Used as a nose but he’s not thicc enough for doubles IMO. But my god does he HUSTLE, got that DAWG
14	Kwon Alexander	A little better in coverage than the other two, had some decent plays but overall average
15	Calvin Austin	Explosive speed, rest of game is lacking
16	Markus Golden	Great rotational pass rush piece, sadly not incredible against the run
17	Pat Freiermuth	Wasn’t utilized enough when healthy, hope that changes when he gets back
18	Connor Heyward	Not a great blocker, but seems to get the job of getting open in space down
19	Isaac Seumalo	Struggled HEAVY against SF but since then has been real solid, makes a bit of sense since he was mostly a RG in Phi but LG with us
20	Nick Herbig	Needs many more reps, give TJ/Highsmith more breaks and let the young kid get his feet wetter
21	Patrick Peterson	Let up some big plays but sadly is our best CB besides JPJ
22	Kenny Pickett	Hard to separate his issues from Canada’s, def left some plays on the board
23	Armon Watts	Nothing special, doesn’t have a ton of reps
24	Damontae Kazee	This is about the meh line for me, everyone below this needs major improvement. Kazee has been very meh, not a good tackler, not crazy valuable in coverage either
25	James Daniels	Regressed from last year and now injured
26	Allen Robinson	Has some nice hands but lacks explosiveness and some lazy routes it seems
27	Chukwuma Okorafor	Brutal work at RT, def look to upgrade this position. I can’t believe he makes 8 figures a year
28	Darnell Washington	He was supposed to be a better blocker than this. Coach also doesn’t utilize his strengths well
29	Nate Herbig	About as good as Daniels (not great) but has played less
30	DeMarvin Leal	Disappointing, so streaky, he’ll have a great play then be replacement level on others
31	Isaiahh Loudermilk	Just is not stout enough
32	Levi Wallace	Burnt toast, not great against the run, slow
33	Mason Cole	This guy is getting shoved in lockers
34	Chandon Sullivan	Don’t hear his name much but take it from me looks way more cooked than Wallace, which is tough to do
35	Dan Moore Jr.	The best thing that’s happened to Pitt’s offenses is his injury